Friday, April 29, 2011

Validation explosion...

Validation: Validity, in logic, determining whether a statement is true or false; to declare or make legally valid; to mark with an indication of official sanction; assessment of an action, decision, plan, or transaction to establish that it is (1) correct, (2) complete, (3) being implemented (and/or recorded) as intended, and (4) delivering the intended outcome.

Upsi has created a safe place for people to discuss their struggles with dealing with narcissistic personalties. Today, at her site You Don't Have to Dance for Them, a discussion was raised about validation. I replied, and was shocked by how strongly I reacted. I felt like I'd exploded, not in tears or hurt but fury. Hours later, now, I'm able to recognize why I reacted the way I did.

Several things came together, at once: In the article posted earlier this week, validation is part of the equation. Today, I finished reading SEALed Forever by Mary Margret Daughtridge, in which validation plays a significant role in the conflict for both the hero and heroine. And my ongoing journey.

The quoted blogger made the statement that validation was unnecessary. "We never need to justify hurt or turn it into suffering via a perceived need for validation. We only need to act on its motivation heal, correct, and improve."

I re-read the above quote, and I'm irritated all over again. Validating isn't about justifying my hurt; it is about recognizing that I AM hurt and not making it up, as I was repeatedly told. Healing requires acknowledging there is an injury. I lost count, long ago, the number of times I was hit, pinched, belittled, insulted, ignored, and more and told, "That didn't hurt!" "I didn't hit you that hard." "Stop whining." "Stop complaining." "You're blowing it out of proportion." "You're being overly sensitive." "You're letting your imagination run away with you." "You're making it up." "It isn't as bad as you're making it out." "You're such a 'girl'." "No one will believe you." "You have nothing to cry about." "You want to cry? I'll give you something to cry about." "You asked for it." "You want to play the poor-is-me game? I'll play it and win."

Needing validation is a part of being human. A baby will cry when they are hungry, tired, or don't feel good: and we validate them by feeding them, rocking them to sleep, or cuddling them when they're cranky. A baby is not seeking justification for crying. They do need to know they are not alone, and someone will meet the needs they cannot because those needs are real and reasonable.

Simply because we've grown up does not mean we're now capable of meeting all our own needs. We are not. Anyone who works, be it in an office, outside, or in the home, they are meeting the needs of someone else. Any time you go to the store, the bank, the post office, make a phone call, use the computer, drive a car, fly, etc, then someone else is meeting your need. Anyone who has a family or friends is meeting the needs for companionship, for self and someone else. It's the way people are made. We spend a remarkable amount of our time dependent on others. This isn't a bad thing. In fact, it's incredibly amazing that we are able to connect the way we do.

Needing validation is not silly or stupid or unreasonable. Being able to validate requires a level of honesty. You have to honestly acknowledge that the feeling/need exists and is real. There are those in my life who will never be able to validate me because it would require acknowledging the lies in their own lives first. I don't anticipate that happening any time soon. However, I have discovered that I don't need their validation that my feelings and needs are reasonable and real. I have found an incredible circle of friends who recognize and acknowledge (thereby validating me) that my feelings and needs are both real and reasonable. Knowing it's real is HUGE. Knowing it's real means I can stop wondering if I'm crazy and start working towards a better solution than the ones that definitely haven't worked in the past, like living in denial.

Are there times when I'm whiney and unreasonable? Absolutely, without a doubt. I also allow myself to be validated that that is also simply being human and not criminal behavior. Undesirable, but not criminal. I'm allowed to have bad days. There is strength in working things through on my own. There is also strength is seeking help and allowing others to lift me, and being allowed to return the favor.

There are plenty of people who are more than willing to live in the lies and pretend like everything is fine. The Emperor's New Clothes sound familiar? Following the logic of the statement above: Then there was no reason for the child to point out that the emperor had no clothes. It was obvious. Validation was unnecessary. However, the point of the story is that sometimes validation is critical in order to move forward in the truth.

I think I'm ready to step down from my soapbox now, at least for today.

6 comments:

  1. That is an awesome post. Thank you.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Wow! It is funny that we "think" we know what a word means, but then someone breaks it down into real terms. Thanks for this very thought provoking and honest look at validation. My mind is now digesting.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Great post, Judy.

    The opening few lines really grabbed my attention:
    Validation is the "assessment of an action...to establish that...it is delivering the intended outcome." I think things get really hazy for most people when we start talking about intentions. And people who seek to invalidate often do so by claiming their intentions were different then their actions would suggest. Narcs don't like it when we surmise that they had "bad" intentions, based on their actions towards us. But, in reality, I believe we have every right to make judgments about their intentions when we feel they are acting in a way that is hurtful.

    I guess what I'm trying to say, and I'm really just making a mess of it, is that intentions and validation go hand-in-hand. A person who intends to hurt you, will simultaneously invalidate your thoughts/feelings. It makes sense to, why would they validate your thoughts/feelings about the pain they intended to cause you? If they did, it would mean they had to stop hurting you. And they don't want to!

    Great post!

    Jonsi

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thanks, Ruth.

    EmmySue, I think a lot of confusion happens because we are coming from different perspectives in the meaning of a single word. It's important to be able to clarify definitions.

    Jonsi, you bring up an important aspect: Intention. And you explained it fine. My Ns will swear they didn't mean to hurt me, and maybe they believe it, but even after I've told them they hurt me, they continue the same behavior because THEY don't see it as hurtful. Their point of view is stamped valid, but mine is stamped invalid. It was a horrible eye-opener when I realized that they enjoyed seeing me flinch, seeing me hurt. I couldn't believe it. Then I started talking with friends and reading about others having the same experience. It was painful, but a relief, too. I wasn't imagining it. I wasn't making it up. My point of view is valid. Thanks for your comment!

    ReplyDelete
  5. You're welcome, Judy! DH and I have been discussing the idea of intent and validation recently, particularly because he's going through something very similar with his NM. (He just recently went NC) Essentially, he would say, "Ouch, that hurt." And she would say, "No. It didn't." And he was expected to hide the hurt and put on a smile. He grew up that way. Sounds like your experience was similar.

    I, however, didn't grow up that way. I grew up in an environment where it was safe to express hurt and anger, and the people who hurt you were made accountable for their actions. So I see the way he was treated and think "abuse!!" It's harder for him to see that, but we're working on it.

    And I am not totally undeserving of some blame myself. We recently had a discussion about something that I did - and we each had separate realities about what was going on. He kept saying, "You were attacking me" and I kept saying "No I wasn't!" It took someone with outside perspective to tell me that a better way for me to handle that was by accepting that his reality was different than mine. I was angry with myself for not getting that before it had to be pointed out to me, because on some level I'm totally aware of the whole "separate realities" thing.

    But I accepted that he felt attacked and felt remorse for it. It wasn't my intention to hurt him, but I had to accept that it DID hurt him. That way, we could discuss how each of us could behave differently in the future so that we didn't repeat the same unhealthy behaviors. (That's exactly what that was for me, an unhealthy, unfair behavior.) We're all learning here! Even those of us who came from non-narco households.

    XOXO

    Jonsi

    ReplyDelete
  6. ((Jonsi)) Thanks so much for sharing that! It made me cry, in a good way. It's a wonderful gift of becoming truly healthy that you two are sharing.

    For myself, sometimes (though not always) it's amazing how much hurt disappears when it's acknowledged/validated. In my case, it didn't have to come from the person who hurt me. There have been many occasions when the validation has come from friends who understand and believe me, and that is enough, to know that my response wasn't unreasonable. It's even funny, sometimes, when they respond more strong to what happened than I did.

    I think we all have some narc-like behaviors. The question is whether or not we perpetuate it or choose to make a difference choice. And you are clearly choosing to make different choices. It's an inspiration to me, to know that a different choice truly is possible.

    ReplyDelete

Thank Goodness It's Sunday

~ Breaking Bread with dear friends ~ Visiting with friends ~ Electric fire place/heater ~ Gorgeous weather, being able to open the door in t...